Draft synthesis: Bacterial endotoxin in research-supply… — submissions
The 2 submissions received, published in full with declared interests and secretariat responses.
§2Submissions and responses
2 submissions were received. Each is published in full below with its declared interest, the secretariat response and the disposition. The Institute publishes submissions it did not accept in the same form as those it did.
Intention-to-treat and efficacy-estimand results are combined without distinction
Several contributing trials report both a treatment-policy result and an efficacy result that censors at discontinuation. The draft draws from whichever is reported first in each paper.
The respondent, a trial statistician, states that the two answer different questions, that the difference is substantial where discontinuation is common, and that a synthesis should choose one and say which.
The secretariat accepts this submission. Mixing estimands within a single pooled estimate is a defect of the synthesis rather than of the trials.
The treatment-policy estimand is used throughout as the primary analysis, the efficacy estimand is reported as a secondary analysis where available, and the estimand used is stated in every row of the summary of findings.
Risk-of-bias judgements are reported as an overall rating without the domains
The draft reports a single overall risk-of-bias judgement per study. The respondent states that the overall judgement conceals which domain drove it, and that a reader assessing whether the concern applies to their question needs the domain.
The respondent proposes a domain-level table with the supporting quotation for each judgement.
The secretariat accepts this submission. The overall judgement is a summary of the domains and publishing only the summary makes it uncheckable.
Risk of bias is now reported at domain level for every included study, with the text on which each judgement was based quoted and referenced, and the overall judgement derived from the domains rather than asserted alongside them.
References cited on this page
References are numbered in order of first citation in this document. Each superscript in the text links to its entry below.
- International Organization for Standardization. ISO/IEC 17025:2017 General Requirements for the Competence of Testing and Calibration Laboratories. ISO/IEC Standard 2017;3rd edition. identifier not held by the Institute
Identifiers are reproduced only where the Institute holds them. Where a digital object identifier or PubMed identifier is not shown, the Institute has recorded the journal and year and has not constructed an identifier.